It City
Resume:
World's Greatest Weblog
Did Kirk inflate resume just like Plummer?
I’m starting to wonder if Republican gubernatorial nominee William Brady is looking at the people he is paired with on the GOP ticket, and is shuddering at the thought.
It was earlier this year that we learned that lieutenant governor nominee Jason Plummer had such an resume for a 27-year-old because some of his accomplishments were exaggerations – ie: claiming internships as jobs, military experience that has yet to occur, etc.
NOW, WE’RE AT Memorial Day with the GOP nominee for the U.S. Senate seat from Illinois having to confrontthat he’s claiming military accomplishments he never really achieved.
Does that make the modern-day incarnation of the Illinois Republican Party the equivalent of the 20-year-old kid who works overnight at a 7-Eleven convenience store, and claims during future job interviews that it was a “management” position because he worked alone on that shift?
Mark Kirk, who has kept his position within the Naval Reserve even as he has served the past decade in Congress as the representative from the North Shore suburbs, has had to deal with reports that came out ever so conveniently in time for this holiday weekend about a claim on the resume – one that said he was once named Intelligence Officer of the Year.
He had claimed the award was for his work with the Navy during military actions in Kosovo.
BUT NOW THAT people are looking more closely at the Kirk resume, it seems that officials are saying it was another reservist who received that particular designation – although there also are awards by the intelligence community given out at regional levels.
Kirk is now claiming that it was his entire unit that received an award from the National Military Intelligence Association, which means he won something known as the “Taylor Award,” which doesn’t sound as imposing as the wording his resume used to reflect.
How seriously should we take this, considering that resume inflation is way too common. I remember when I used to have a reporter-type position that occasionally required me to interview prospective interns, I used to routinely find puffery in resumes meant to make someone sound much more impressive than they truly were. It is to the point where I have weeded through my own resume to eliminate as much puffery as possible, in hopes that it would make me stand out from the crowd that I’m not trying to feed a lot of bull to a potential future employer.
I’m sure such personal promotion happens everywhere. Somebody wants to present their best side, and it usually is someone who thinks highly enough of themselves to begin with that they decide in their minds that such overstated rhetoric isn’t that big a deal.
THAT CERTAINLY IS the approach the Kirk campaign is, sending out a statement by e-mail on Sunday meant to downplay the significance of this whole thing.
It is playing off the Washington Post report this weekend that acknowledged the newspaper learned of Kirk’s resume inflation from people who have an interest in promoting the campaign of Democratic challenger Alexi Giannoulias.
This is a lame trick by the political opposition, they want us to believe.
How else to explain a statement that begins with the headline, “’Mob Banker’ who never served attacks decorated Naval officer’s distinguished service record.”
WHICH MEANS THIS was probably a last-minute rewrite of the political cheap shot the Republicans had planned to make public for Memorial Day – Mark Kirk has served in the military, while Alexi Giannoulias has not.
That statement makes such rhetorical flushes as, “while Mark Kirk wore a U.S. Navy uniform, Alexi Giannoulias wore a basketball uniform in Greece” (he played one year professionally for Panionios) and “while Mark Kirk was supporting electronic attack missions over Iraq, Alexi Giannoulias was partying in New Orleans at Tulane Law School.”
What was supposed to be a hard-core partisan shot across the bow of the Campaign Giannoulias to get all those military veterans ticked off enough to vote against him was turned into Kirk having to justify that he really did serve in the Naval Reserve.
It also makes us wonder how much of the rest of his background is inflated. Are we going to find more things? I’d hope not. I’d rather this become a campaign based on issues, even though that is probably a na ve statement on my part.
THESE RHETORICAL FLOURISHES wind up becoming the issues, which means we will have to spend valuable time in coming months trying to figure out which candidate is lying to us less when they tell us about their life’s accomplishments.
So while the Kirk camp tells us that the candidate’s military record, “should not be denigrated by a 34-year-old media-dubbed ‘mob banker’ who has never served our country in uniform,” I wonder if it should be denigrated by a resume padder (which I think says something about someone’s character if they’re that insecure about the bottom-line truth).
More importantly, I wonder if at least a few of those people who served our country in uniform and died to preserve our society are rolling over in their graves at the thought that these two are the best that the major political parties could come up with to run for one of the highest political posts in the land.
-30-
Gregory Tejeda
at
12:01 AM
Labels:,,,,,,,,
No comments:
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
"The Front Page," 21st Century style
New York Times (Chicago search)St. Louis Post-Dispatch (Illinois edition)The Times of Northwest Indiana (Illinois edition), Munster, Ind.
Issue oriented reporting
Arab American Times (ethnic)Capitol Fax (state government)Catalyst (public education)Catholic New World (Archdiocese newspaper)Chicago Catholic News (religion)Chicago Chinese News (ethnic)Chicago Daily Law Bulletin (legal issues)Chicago is the World (ethnic)Chicago Jewish News (religion)Chicago Reporter (urban affairs)Chicagoside (sports)Chicago Union News (organized labor)Chicago Wildlife News (environment)"Clout City," Chicago Reader (city government)Crain's Chicago BusinessEarly and Often (archives, Chicago News Cooperative)ESPN Chicago (sports)Illinois Corruption (legal issues)Illinois Elections (Lee Enterprises campaign coverage)Illinois Issues (state government)Illinoize (state government)India Bulletin (ethnic)India Tribune (ethnic)Informacje USA (ethnic)Korea Daily News (ethnic)Korea Times (ethnic)"News Bites," Chicago Reader (journalism)NWI Elections (Lee Enterprises campaign coverage)Pinoy (ethnic)Polish Daily News (ethnic)Stateline -- Illinois (government)"Ward Room," WMAQ-TV (government)Windy City Times (gay rights)
Commentary worthy of your attention
Roger Ebert's Journal, Chicago Sun-TimesGreg Hinz, Crain's Chicago Business
News from the 'Hood
The Other Two-Thirds of Chicagoland
Journal & Topics, Des PlainesPatch.com (AOL's attempt to make money off local news coverage)Villa Park Argus (I like their name)
La Ciudad Segunda
Catolico (Archdiocese newspaper)Diario de Mexico (Chicago edition)Extra (bilingual news from Humboldt Park)Hoy (the Tribune’s daily attempt to cover Chicago en Espa ol) Que Viva!, Merrillville, Ind.Reflejos, Arlington Heights (covering the suburbs in both Espa ol y English)WGBO-TV, Ch. 66 (Univision)WSNS-TV, Ch. 44 (Telemundo)
Following the legacy set by Len O'Connor, Fahey Flynn and Bill & Walter
"At Issue," WBBM-AM"Beyond the Beltway," Bruce DuMont"Chicago Tonight," WTTW-TV"Connected to Chicago" with Bill Cameron, WLS-AM"Eight Forty-Eight," WBEZ-FM"Illinois Lawmakers," PBS"Lakeshore News," WYIN-TV, Merrillville, Ind."Skilling Central," WGN-TV"State Week in Review," WUIS-FM, Springfield"The Sunday Papers," WGN-AM
Chicago journalism-in-training
The Argus, Illinois Wesleyan University, Bloomington (this weblog's namesake)Chicago Flame, University of Illinois – ChicagoDaily Illini, University of Illinois – Urbana
Out-of-towners who are not clueless about news
"Ask A Mexican," (Gustavo Arellano's column is not published in any Chicago-area newspapers)"Indiana Barrister," Abdul Hakim Shabazz"Meet the Press," NBC"Morning Express" with Robin Meade, CNN HeadlineNew Orleans Levee (news parody, by an ex-Chicago reporter-type)"Supplied to Anderson," Paul Anderson
What do the stars (and stripes) stand for?
Second City's Culture ...
Budget Cooking Blog (from a reporter-turned-chef, which may well be a step up in contributing to society)Chicago (the magazine)Chicago neighborhoods (map)Chicago White Sox "first fan"EarthCam – Chicago, The Field MuseumEvery Block -- Chicago (crime statistics by neighborhood)Field's Fans ChicagoGaper's BlockGayety's chocolates and ice creamLee Bey's ChicagoThe Outfit (Chicago Writer's Collective)Resident's JournalSiskel & Ebert (archives)WGLT-FM, Normal (this NPR affiliate offers better jazz music programming than any Chicago radio station)
... & Its Politics
Chicago for Rahm (is it really?)"Blue Room" Stream"McHenry County," former state Rep. Cal Skinner
Gregory Tejeda
Chicago's far South Side, Illinois, United StatesI am a Chicago-area freelance writer who has reported on various political and legal beats. I wrote "Hispanic" issues columns for United Press International, observed up close the Statehouse Scene in Springfield, Ill., and for a time, I also wrote about agriculture. Trust me when I say the symbolic stench of partisan politics (particularly when directed against people due to their ethnicity) is far nastier than any odor that could come from a farm animal.
Chicago Argus contact ...
************@*****.***
Chicago Argus archive
(1)
(1)
(378)
(33)
(32)
(32)
(31)
(32)
(31)
(31)
Contact this candidate